In the chaos of the French Revolution, churches were being plundered; as the revolutionaries closed in on religious life, the prioress of one convent suggested to her community that they set their hearts on martyrdom, offering themselves as a sacrifice for France and the Church. A few months later, monasteries were closed, the nuns were forced out into the world, and religious habits were outlawed. The 16 Carmelite nuns hid in four different places and courageously continued to practice their prayer. In 1794, they were discovered and imprisoned, accused of being “criminals and annihilators of public freedom,” and sentenced to death. As they were paraded in front of the angry, insulting crowds in an open cart on their way to the guillotine, they sang. In a moving moment, as they disembarked the cart, they knelt and chanted the “Veni Creator” and renewed their vows, then forgave their guards and together sang Laudate Dominum (Psalm 116), each nun’s chant being silenced by the blade. Their bodies were burned, along with 128 other victims executed that day.
Evil may seem to triumph, but the true victory is already won, and every evil is only allowed by God because it can ultimately resound to His glory and our eternal good.
Today is the Feast of the Holy Innocents. What is more evil than ordering the horrendous murder of innocent children? And yet, the Church’s prayer today insists that these holy innocents offered praise to God by the death they suffered for Christ. This pushes against our own natural understanding: How can something so horrific give praise to God?
If we step back from the “sobbing and loud lamentation,” we can see the wider cosmic theater: the devil is in perpetual rebellion against God and all that He has created (including us), and all evil and suffering come from this rebellion in some way. When innocent people suffer, it is as if they are “caught in the crossfire” of this war “against the spiritual forces of evil” (Eph. 6:12), and bearing the evil that is ultimately directed at God.
Because the horror of Herod’s order to murder children was intended for Christ, their suffering was for Christ. The evil that was directed toward Jesus fell upon them.
God’s response to the question of why innocent people suffer is Christ. Christ came to take upon Himself and redeem all suffering, making it a path to salvation. This is why the martyrs and saints receive suffering as a gift, and can see their own death as union with Jesus Christ. This is why those Carmelite nuns helped each other climb the scaffold as they sang praises to God.
Ten short days after the nuns of Compiegne were martyred, Robespierre himself was executed, ending the Reign of Terror (if you are interested in hearing more of their story, read The Song at the Scaffold.). French Catholics attributed this to the holy martyrdom of these innocent nuns.
Lord, help us to join our suffering to yours today!